All-Time All-ODAC First Team Selections
| Year | Name | Position | ||
| 1976 | Mike Roberts | Quarterback | ||
| Ron Mabry | Wide Receiver | |||
| Chris Mawdsley | Offensive Line | |||
| Keith Sturgill | Defensive End | |||
| 1977 | Mike Snow | Tight End | ||
| Keith Sturgill | Defensive End | |||
| Chip Hill | Defensive Back | |||
| 1978 | Marty Browder | Quarterback | ||
| Johnny Wilson | Wide Receiver | |||
| Steve Hurley | Offensive Tackle | |||
| Chip Hill | Defensive Back | |||
| Jeff Stone | Linebacker | |||
| Jeff Stone | Kicker | |||
| 1979 | Steve Irvin | Defensive End | ||
| Don Glass | Defensive Back | |||
| 1980 | Barry Bailey | Offensive Guard | ||
| Howard Hoyt | Offensive Tackle | |||
| David Blair | Defensive Back | |||
| 1981 | Stevie Allen | Wide Receiver | ||
| Mike Keating | Defensive Back | |||
| 1982 | Steve Larus | Tight End | ||
| Rob McMillen | Defensive Line | |||
| 1983 | Stevie Allen | Wide Receiver | ||
| Rob McMillen | Defensive Line | |||
| Wayne Hall | Defensive Back | |||
| 1984 | Sandy Rogers | Running Back | ||
| Stevie Allen | Wide Receiver | |||
| Steve Larus | Tight End | |||
| Glenn Spangler | Offensive Line | |||
| Rob McMillen | Defensive Line | |||
| Troy Chandler | Defensive Line | |||
| Mike Lindsay | Defensive Back | |||
| 1985 | Sandy Rogers | Running Back | ||
| Jeff Keys | Offensive Line | |||
| Glenn Spangler | Offensive Line | |||
| Jack Ginn | Kicker | |||
| Troy Chandler | Defensive Line | |||
| Rob McMillen | Defensive Line | |||
| David Davis | Linebacker | |||
| Keith Furr | Defensive Back | |||
| 1986 | Sandy Rogers # | Running Back | ||
| Gary Collier | Quarterback | |||
| Steve Dean | Offensive Line | |||
| Troy Chandler | Defensive Line | |||
| H.O. Lyne | Defensive Line | |||
| David Kassnove | Linebacker | |||
| Keith Furr | Defensive Back | |||
| 1987 | Gary Collier # | Quarterback | ||
| Paul Overbay | Wide Receiver | |||
| F.T. Johnson | Tight End | |||
| Taylor Lyne | Offensive Line | |||
| Stacey Whitt | Linebacker | |||
| Mike Stup | Defensive Back | |||
| 1988 | Rodney Beville | Running Back | ||
| John Lakey | Wide Receiver | |||
| Paul Overbay | Wide Receiver | |||
| B.I. Salyers | Offensive Line | |||
| John Willson | Offensive Line | |||
| Steve Bowman | Defensive Line | |||
| Doug Reavis | Defensive Back | |||
| 1989 | B.I. Salyers | Offensive Line | ||
| John Willson | Offensive Line | |||
| Jason Grooms | Defensive Line | |||
| Steve Sallee | Defensive End | |||
| Doug Reavis | Defensive Back | |||
| 1990 | B.I. Salyers # | Offensive Line | ||
| Pat Walker | Quarterback | |||
| Scotty Verran | Running Back | |||
| Cary Perkins | Wide Receiver | |||
| Brad Bowman | Defensive Line | |||
| Steve Munsey | Defensive Back | |||
| 1991 | Billy Allen | Running Back | ||
| Jim Brooks | Offensive Line | |||
| Patrick Buchanan | Offensive Line | |||
| Jason Grooms | Defensive Line | |||
| Scott Pruner | Defensive End | |||
| Darren Reed | Linebacker | |||
| Wes Pilgrim | Defensive Back | |||
| 1992 | Cary Perkins # | Quarterback | ||
| John Ely | Tight End | |||
| Reid Ebert | Offensive Center | |||
| Patrick Buchanan | Offensive Line | |||
| Drew Bishop | Offensive Line | |||
| Mike Powell | Defensive Line | |||
| Scott Pruner | Defensive End | |||
| Adam Dowe | Defensive End | |||
| Mike Stansbury | Linebacker | |||
| Scott Cox | Defensive Back | |||
| 1993 | Todd Woodall | Wide Receiver | ||
| John Ely | Tight End | |||
| Reid Ebert | Offensive Center | |||
| Rex Carter | Offensive Line | |||
| Mike Powell | Defensive Line | |||
| Adam Dowe | Defensive End | |||
| Darren Reed | Linebacker | |||
| Ricky Webb | Defensive Back | |||
| Mark Middleton | Punter | |||
| 1994 | Aaron Fuller | Wide Receiver | ||
| Kevin Rogers | Offensive Line | |||
| Wade Vidal | Kicker | |||
| Steve Godsey | Defensive End | |||
| Darren Reed | Linebacker | |||
| Mark Middleton | Punter | |||
| 1995 | J.D. Davis | Running Back | ||
| Chris Turner | Tight End | |||
| Jody Carter | Offensive Line | |||
| Kevin Rogers | Offensive Line | |||
| Burt Torrence | Defensive Line | |||
| Chris Barbour | Defensive End | |||
| Larry Arwood | Linebacker | |||
| Gerald Jones | Defensive Back | |||
| Thomas Nelson | Defensive Back | |||
| 1997 | Oliver Jordan | Running Back | ||
| Aaron Fuller | Wide Receiver | |||
| Micheal Hughes | Offensive Line | |||
| Jamie Harless | Defensive Tackle | |||
| Mike Kassnove | Defensive End | |||
| Larry Arwood | Linebacker | |||
| 1998 | Oliver Jordan # | Running Back | ||
| Todd Mounts | Tight End | |||
| Micheal Hughes | Offensive Line | |||
| Temple Musser | Offensive Line | |||
| Mike Kassnove | Defensive End | |||
| Isaac Williams | Defensive Tackle | |||
| John Carmody | Linebacker | |||
| Chris Ratcliffe | Cornerback | |||
| Charles Peterson | Safety | |||
| 1999 | Oliver Jordan | Running Back | ||
| Micheal Hughes | Offensive Line | |||
| Chris Epperly | Kicker | |||
| Earl Jefferson | Defensive Line | |||
| Charles Peterson | Defensive Back | |||
| Chris Epperly | Punter | |||
| 2000 | Nathan Tuck | Wide Receiver | ||
| Anthony Church | Offensive Line | |||
| Jelani Patterson | Defensive End | |||
| Nolan Jeffries | Linebacker | |||
| Chris Ratcliffe | Defensive Back | |||
| 2001 | Jelani Patterson | Defensive End | ||
| Phil Christian | Linebacker | |||
| Jay Clark | Cornerback | |||
| 2002 | Jay Clark | Defensive Back | ||
| 2003 | Jeremy Hagee | Defensive Tackle | ||
| 2004 | Todd Woods | Quarterback | ||
| Chris Miller | Running Back | |||
| Jared Jackson | Wide Receiver | |||
| J.D. Overton | Offensive Line | |||
| 2006 | Marshall Doss # | Linebacker | ||
| Matt Baldwin | Defensive Line | |||
| 2007 | Josh Clawson | Offensive Line | ||
| Luke Hawk | Kicker | |||
| Matt Baldwin | Defensive Line | |||
| Evin O'Sullivan | Linebacker | |||
| 2008 | Caleb Jennings | Running Back | ||
| Chris Mickno | Offensive Line | |||
| Matt Baldwin | Defensive End | |||
| Dustin Rexrode | Defensive Tackle | |||
| Kevin Worley | Linebacker | |||
| Joey Daniels | Defensive Back | |||
| Luke Hawk | Kicker | |||
| 2009 | Caleb Jennings # | Running Back | ||
| Corey Sheperd | Tight End | |||
| James Hairston | Offensive Line | |||
| Ed Smith | Linebacker | |||
| T.J. Frazier | Punter | |||
| 2010 | Caleb Jennings | Running Back | ||
| Daniel Woods | Defensive Back | |||
| 2011 | Ben Johnson | Offensive Line | ||
| Devan Sproles # | Linebacker | |||
| Daniel Preston | Defensive End | |||
| T.J. Frazier | Punter | |||
| 2014 | Donovan Sudderth | Offensive Line | ||
| Paul Forney | Linebacker | |||
| 2015 | McFarland Murph | Offensive Line | ||
| Skyler Simcox | Kicker | |||
| Tre’von Lightfoot | Defensive Back | |||
| 2016 | McFarland Murph | Offensive Line | ||
| Da’von Keith | Defensive Line | |||
| Rhasheen Williams | Linebacker | |||
| Tre’von Lightfoot | Defensive Back | |||
| 2017 | Josh Fleenor | Defensive Line | ||
| 2018 | Tyler Weterrings | Offensive Line | ||
| 2019 | Derrick Yates | Wide Receiver | ||
| Tyler Weterrings | Offensive Line | |||
| Josh Fleenor | Defensive Line | |||
| Da'von Keith | Defensive Line | |||
| Ivan Phillips | Linebacker | |||
| 2020* | Grayson Overstreet | Running Back | ||
| Elijah Rice | Wide Receiver | |||
| Dakota Morris | Offensive Line | |||
| Donovan Pinnix | Defensive Line | |||
| Jay Swegheimer # | Defensive Line | |||
| Ivan Phillips | Linebacker | |||
| Jaylyn Kreimes | Defensive Back | |||
| # Denotes ODAC Player of the Year | ||||
All-Time All-SAC First Team Selections
| Year | Name | Position | ||
| 2022* | Grayson Overstreet | Running Back | ||
| Tmahdae Penn | Wide Receiver | |||
| Ricky Dodson | Offensive Line | |||
| Donovan Pinnix | Defensive Line | |||
| Ivan Phillips | Linebacker | |||
| 2023 | Ethan Muncy | Punter | ||
| 2024 | Jordan Jackson | Running Back | ||
| Cam Abshire | Wide Receiver | |||
| Deshaun Sharp | Offensive Line | |||
| Kaleb Lundy | Linebacker | |||
| Jarrell Harrison | Defensive Back | |||
| 2025 | Jordan Jackson | Running Back | ||
| Deshaun Sharp | Offensive Line | |||
| Ean Rhea ! | Defensive Line | |||
| Shawn Collins | Defensive Back | |||
| Trace Butcher | Kicker | |||
| *First Team All-Mountain Division selections | ||||
| ! Denotes SAC Player of the Year | ||||
-