| 1976 - (4-6 overall, 2-2 ODAC) | ||||
| Head Coach: Jimmy Hughes | ||||
| James Madison | H | 20-26 | L | |
| Washington and Lee * | A | 24-17 | W | |
| Guilford | A | 14-24 | L | |
| Catawba | H | 7-35 | L | |
| Concord | H | 10-6 | W | |
| Randolph-Macon * | H | 21-28 | L | |
| Bridgewater * | H | 35-13 | W | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | A | 6-28 | L | |
| Bluefield State | H | 24-22 | W | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) | A | 28-34 | L | |
| 1977 - (3-7 overall, 2-2 ODAC) | ||||
| Head Coach: Fred Selfe | ||||
| James Madison | A | 3-7 | L | |
| Guilford | H | 7-14 | L | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) | H | 6-21 | L | |
| Catawba | A | 7-51 | L | |
| Concord | A | 3-14 | L | |
| Randolph-Macon * | A | 12-24 | L | |
| Bridgewater * | A | 42-20 | W | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | H | 20-38 | L | |
| Washington and Lee * | H | 7-6 | W | |
| West Virginia Wesleyen | H | 30-0 | W | |
| 1978 - (2-7 overall, 2-2 ODAC) | ||||
| Head Coach: Jerry Kirk | ||||
| Concord | H | 7-41 | L | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) | A | 6-17 | L | |
| Guilford | A | 18-26 | L | |
| Millsaps | H | 14-31 | L | |
| Randolph-Macon * | H | 14-42 | L | |
| Bridgewater * | H | 27-20 | W | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | A | 12-13 | L | |
| Washington and Lee * | A | 18-17 | W | |
| James Madison | H | 12-42 | L | |
| 1979 - (4-6 overall, 2-2 ODAC) (all-time series will count loss) | ||||
| Head Coach: Larry Bales | ||||
| Concord | A | 0-30 | L | |
| Washington and Lee * | H | 12-6 | W | |
| Guilford | H | 7-24 | L | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) | H | 14-30 | L | |
| Millsaps | A | 18-42 | L | |
| Randolph-Macon * | A | 6-18 | L | |
| Bridgewater * | A | 21-0 | W | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | H | 3-21 | L | |
| Central Florida | H | 28-14 | W | |
| Gardner-Webb | A | 7-21 | L* (forfeit) | |
| 1980 - (2-8 overall, 1-4 ODAC) | ||||
| Head Coach: Larry Bales | ||||
| Guilford | A | 0-31 | L | |
| Concord | H | 7-35 | L | |
| Washington and Lee * | A | 14-28 | L | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) * | A | 6-13 | L | |
| Randolph-Macon * | H | 18-15 | W | |
| Hampton | H | 27-38 | L | |
| Bridgewater * | H | 14-15 | L | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | A | 10-29 | L | |
| Centre | H | 23-7 | W | |
| Central Florida | A | 14-18 | L | |
| 1981 - (1-8-1 overall, 0-4-1 ODAC) | ||||
| Head Coach: Larry Bales | ||||
| Guilford | H | 0-23 | L | |
| Concord | A | 0-48 | L | |
| Washington and Lee * | H | 17-24 | L | |
| Georgetown (Ky.) | H | 21-3 | W | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) * | H | 10-14 | L | |
| Hampton | A | 17-50 | L | |
| Randolph-Macon * | A | 0-24 | L | |
| Bridgewater * | A | 19-19 | T | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | H | 6-31 | L | |
| Centre | A | 14-39 | L | |
| 1982 - (3-6 overall, 2-3 ODAC) | ||||
| Head Coach: Lou Wacker | ||||
| Guilford | A | 7-57 | L | |
| Catholic | H | 14-21 | L | |
| Washington and Lee * | A | 15-21 | L | |
| Georgetown (Ky.) | A | 21-20 | W | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) * | A | 7-12 | L | |
| Waynesburg | H | 12-20 | L | |
| Randolph-Macon * | H | 20-24 | L | |
| Bridgewater * | H | 28-21 | W | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | A | 14-12 | W | |
| 1983 - (5-5 overall, 4-2 ODAC) | ||||
| Head Coach: Lou Wacker | ||||
| Catholic * | A | 21-13 | W | |
| Washington and Lee * | H | 21-14 | W | |
| Georgetown (Ky.) | H | 0-20 | L | |
| Guilford | H | 0-16 | L | |
| Waynesburg | A | 7-24 | L | |
| Randolph-Macon * | A | 15-17 | L | |
| Bridgewater * | A | 21-3 | W | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | H | 0-13 | L | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) * | H | 27-10 | W | |
| Georgia Southwestern | A | 25-13 | W | |
| 1984 - (6-4 overall, 3-2 ODAC) | ||||
| Head Coach: Lou Wacker | ||||
| Centre | H | 19-14 | W | |
| Washington and Lee * | A | 28-0 | W | |
| Georgetown (Ky.) | A | 0-17 | L | |
| Guilford | A | 0-13 | L | |
| Union (Ky.) | H | 56-0 | W | |
| Randolph-Macon * | H | 26-31 | L | |
| Bridgewater * | H | 42-7 | W | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | A | 7-10 | L | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) * | A | 49-6 | W | |
| Georgia Southwestern | H | 17-10 | W | |
| 1985 - (8-3 overall, 4-1 ODAC) | ODAC Co-Champions | |||
| Head Coach: Lou Wacker | ||||
| Ferrum | 8-15 | L | ||
| Washington and Lee * | 30-0 | W | ||
| Bridgewater * | 35-22 | W | ||
| Samford | 48-32 | W | ||
| Tennessee Wesleyan | 62-12 | W | ||
| Hampden-Sydney * | 31-10 | W | ||
| Randolph-Macon * | 14-17 | L | ||
| Cumberland | 48-6 | W | ||
| Union | 20-10 | W | ||
| Centre | 17-21 | L | ||
| Maryville (Tenn.) * | 42-6 | W | ||
| 1986 - (10-2 overall, 5-0 ODAC) | ODAC Champions | |||
| Head Coach: Lou Wacker | NCAA Playoffs | |||
| Ferrum | N | 7-6 | W | |
| Washington and Lee * | A | 31-9 | W | |
| Bridgewater * | H | 35-9 | W | |
| Tennessee Wesleyan | H | 63-12 | W | |
| Dickinson | A | 35-9 | W | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | A | 14-10 | W | |
| Randolph-Macon * | H | 45-7 | W | |
| Cumberland | A | 13-10 | W | |
| Centre | H | 17-18 | L | |
| Samford | A | 49-3 | W | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) * | N | 55-7 | W | |
| Salisbury State # | H | 35-20 | L | |
| 1987 - (11-3 overall, 4-1 ODAC) | ||||
| Head Coach: Lou Wacker | NCAA Playoffs | |||
| Ferrum | N | 20-21 | L | |
| Washington and Lee * | H | 42-19 | W | |
| Bridgewater * | A | 42-7 | W | |
| Tennessee Wesleyan | H | 48-6 | W | |
| Dickinson | A | 48-0 | W | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | H | 13-14 | L | |
| Randolph-Macon * | A | 35-6 | W | |
| Samford | H | 56-37 | W | |
| Centre | A | 42-17 | W | |
| Sewanee | H | 55-12 | W | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) * | A | 54-23 | W | |
| Ferrum # | H | 49-7 | W | |
| Washington & Jefferson # | A | 23-16 | W | |
| Wagner # | H | 15-20 | L | |
| 1988 - (8-2 overall, 4-0 ODAC) | ODAC Champions | |||
| Head Coach: Lou Wacker | ||||
| Ferrum | A | 14-22 | L | |
| Washington and Lee * | A | 41-12 | W | |
| Bridgewater * | H | 21-7 | W | |
| Tennessee Wesleyan | A | 41-0 | W | |
| Guilford | A | 31-17 | W | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | A | 21-14 | W | |
| Randolph-Macon * | H | 32-15 | W | |
| Centre | H | 13-19 | L | |
| Samford | A | 21-19 | W | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) | H | 40-14 | W | |
| 1989 - (6-4 overall, 3-1 ODAC) | ||||
| Head Coach: Lou Wacker | ||||
| Washington and Lee * | H | 36-25 | W | |
| Bridgewater * | A | 31-7 | W | |
| Tennessee Wesleyan | H | 44-0 | W | |
| Millsaps | A | 6-7 | L | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | H | 31-10 | W | |
| Randolph-Macon * | A | 10-14 | L | |
| Guilford | H | 10-5 | W | |
| Centre | A | 3-14 | L | |
| Ferrum | H | 14-48 | L | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) | A | 29-13 | W | |
| 1990 - (6-4 overall, 4-0 ODAC) | ODAC Champions | |||
| Head Coach: Lou Wacker | ||||
| Washington and Lee * | A | 22-21 | W | |
| Bridgewater * | H | 49-14 | W | |
| Davidson | A | 27-31 | L | |
| Millsaps | H | 20-17 | W | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | A | 21-20 | W | |
| Randolph-Macon * | H | 25-0 | W | |
| Guilford | A | 34-41 | L | |
| Wittenburg | H | 34-41 | L | |
| Ferrum | A | 24-56 | L | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) | H | 61-7 | W | |
| 1991 - (8-2 overall, 4-1 ODAC) | ||||
| Head Coach: Lou Wacker | ||||
| Washington and Lee * | H | 14-0 | W | |
| Bridgewater * | A | 16-0 | W | |
| Davidson | H | 39-14 | W | |
| Millsaps | A | 6-14 | L | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | H | 21-0 | W | |
| Randolph-Macon * | A | 21-10 | W | |
| Guilford * | H | 16-17 | L | |
| Wittenburg | A | 35-17 | W | |
| Ferrum | H | 28-10 | W | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) | A | 20-8 | W | |
| 1992 - (11-1 overall, 5-0 ODAC) | ODAC Champions | |||
| Head Coach: Lou Wacker | NCAA Playoffs | |||
| Cumberland (Ky.) | H | 49-6 | W | |
| Washington and Lee * | A | 41-13 | W | |
| Bridgewater * | H | 51-6 | W | |
| Davidson | A | 36-7 | W | |
| Millsaps | H | 17-6 | W | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | A | 13-7 | W | |
| Randolph-Macon * | H | 21-3 | W | |
| Guilford * | A | 41-0 | W | |
| Ferrum | A | 21-14 | W | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) | H | 24-14 | W | |
| Thomas More # | H | 17-0 | W | |
| Washington & Jefferson # | A | 15-51 | L | |
| 1993 - (7-3 overall, 4-1 ODAC) | ||||
| Head Coach: Lou Wacker | ||||
| Cumberland (Ky.) | A | 15-8 | W | |
| Washington and Lee * | H | 36-6 | W | |
| Bridgewater * | A | 28-7 | W | |
| Davidson | H | 27-0 | W | |
| Millsaps | A | 10-34 | L | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | H | 10-7 | W | |
| Randolph-Macon * | A | 6-20 | L | |
| Guilford * | H | 46-14 | W | |
| Ferrum | H | 16-13 | W | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) | A | 28-29 | L | |
| 1994 - (8-2 overall, 4-1 ODAC) | ODAC Champions | |||
| Head Coach: Lou Wacker | ||||
| Washington and Lee * | A | 23-2 | W | |
| Bridgewater * | H | 47-6 | W | |
| Davidson | A | 34-7 | W | |
| Millsaps | H | 54-14 | W | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | A | 35-17 | W | |
| Randolph-Macon * | H | 14-0 | W | |
| Guilford * | A | 14-24 | L | |
| Clinch Valley | H | 35-31 | W | |
| Ferrum | A | 21-43 | L | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) | H | 42-19 | W | |
| 1995 - (9-2 overall, 5-0 ODAC) | ODAC Champions | |||
| Head Coach: Lou Wacker | NCAA Playoffs | |||
| Washington and Lee * | H | 35-22 | W | |
| Bridgewater * | A | 21-0 | W | |
| Davidson | H | 32-0 | W | |
| Millsaps | A | 34-17 | W | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | H | 17-0 | W | |
| Randolph-Macon * | A | 17-14 | W | |
| Guilford * | H | 38-6 | W | |
| Clinch Valley | A | 29-20 | W | |
| Ferrum | H | 14-7 | W | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) | A | 3-6 | L | |
| Washington & Jefferson # | A | 16-35 | L | |
| 1996 - (8-2 overall, 4-1 ODAC) | ODAC Champions | |||
| Head Coach: Lou Wacker | ||||
| Washington & Jefferson | A | 7-27 | L | |
| Bridgewater * | H | 20-14 | W | |
| Davidson | A | 24-17 | W | |
| Millsaps | H | 24-7 | W | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | A | 34-7 | W | |
| Randolph-Macon * | H | 24-20 | W | |
| Guilford * | A | 32-33 | L | |
| Ferrum | H | 29-3 | W | |
| Washington and Lee * | A | 43-27 | W | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) | H | 32-0 | W | |
| 1997 - (8-2 overall, 4-1 ODAC) | ODAC Co-Champions | |||
| Head Coach: Lou Wacker | ||||
| Washington & Jefferson | H | 38-10 | W | |
| Bridgewater * | A | 31-7 | W | |
| Davidson | H | 49-35 | W | |
| Greensboro | A | 37-3 | W | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | H | 33-10 | W | |
| Randolph-Macon * | A | 20-27 | L | |
| Guilford * | H | 35-27 | W | |
| Ferrum | A | 13-10 | W | |
| Washington and Lee * | H | 27-17 | W | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) | A | 24-27 | L | |
| 1998 - (10-0 overall, 5-0 ODAC) | ODAC Champions | |||
| Head Coach: Lou Wacker | ||||
| Washington & Jefferson | A | 12-10 | W | |
| Bridgewater * | H | 14-13 | W | |
| Davidson | A | 27-24 | W | |
| Greensboro | H | 41-10 | W | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | A | 35-14 | W | |
| Randolph-Macon * | H | 27-19 | W | |
| Guilford * | A | 34-20 | W | |
| Ferrum | H | 3-0 | W | |
| Washington and Lee * | A | 23-20 | W | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) | H | 48-0 | W | |
| 1999 - (6-4 overall, 4-2 ODAC) | ||||
| Head Coach: Lou Wacker | ||||
| Washington & Jefferson | H | 17-24 | L | |
| Ferrum | A | 12-7 | W | |
| Bridgewater * | A | 24-21 | W | |
| Davidson | H | 17-13 | W | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | H | 36-7 | W | |
| Randolph-Macon * | A | 23-36 | L | |
| Guilford * | H | 24-7 | W | |
| Catholic * | A | 19-42 | L | |
| Washington and Lee * | H | 23-21 | W | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) | A | 10-21 | L | |
| 2000 - (8-3 overall, 5-1 ODAC) | ODAC Champions | |||
| Head Coach: Lou Wacker | NCAA Playoffs | |||
| Ferrum | A | 10-0 | W | |
| Bridgewater * | H | 37-35 | W | |
| Davidson | A | 14-17 | L | |
| Averett | H | 54-7 | W | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | A | 37-14 | W | |
| Randolph-Macon * | H | 24-17 | W | |
| Guilford * | A | 41-32 | W | |
| Catholic * | H | 40-50 | L | |
| Washington and Lee * | A | 24-10 | W | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) | H | 34-17 | W | |
| Western Maryland # | H | 14-38 | L | |
| 2001 - (5-5 overall, 3-3 ODAC) | ||||
| Head Coach: Lou Wacker | ||||
| Methodist | A | 20-16 | W | |
| Ferrum | H | 38-6 | W | |
| Sewanee | A | 13-20 | L | |
| Davidson | H | 6-23 | L | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | H | 34-20 | W | |
| Randolph-Macon * | A | 24-8 | W | |
| Bridgewater * | H | 14-28 | L | |
| Catholic * | A | 21-34 | L | |
| Washington and Lee * | H | 35-17 | W | |
| Guilford * | A | 7-17 | L | |
| 2002 - (4-6 overall, 2-4 ODAC) | ||||
| Head Coach: Lou Wacker | ||||
| Methodist | H | 15-25 | L | |
| Ferrum | A | 13-10 | W | |
| Sewanee | H | 25-24 | W | |
| Davidson | A | 7-44 | L | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | A | 13-24 | L | |
| Randolph-Macon * | H | 13-17 | L | |
| Bridgewater * | A | 18-48 | L | |
| Catholic * | H | 48-47 | W | |
| Washington and Lee * | A | 9-22 | L | |
| Guilford * | H | 10-0 | W | |
| 2003 - (5-5 overall, 3-3 ODAC) | ||||
| Head Coach: Lou Wacker | ||||
| Ferrum | H | 0-19 | L | |
| Millsaps | A | 20-14 | W | |
| Davidson | H | 21-45 | L | |
| Methodist | A | 33-30 | W | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | H | 41-54 | L | |
| Randolph-Macon * | A | 7-10 | L | |
| Bridgewater * | H | 17-41 | L | |
| Catholic * | A | 30-16 | W | |
| Washington and Lee * | H | 34-16 | W | |
| Guilford * | A | 35-20 | W | |
| 2004 - (4-6 overall, 3-3 ODAC) | ||||
| Head Coach: Lou Wacker | ||||
| Ferrum | A | 14-24 | L | |
| Millsaps | H | 24-20 | W | |
| Washington & Jefferson | A | 28-76 | L | |
| Methodist | H | 27-36 | L | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | A | 21-52 | L | |
| Randolph-Macon * | H | 48-21 | W | |
| Bridgewater * | A | 38-49 | L | |
| Catholic * | H | 42-13 | W | |
| Washington and Lee * | A | 20-24 | L | |
| Guilford * | H | 49-34 | W | |
| 2005 - (1-9 overall, 1-5 ODAC) | ||||
| Head Coach: Don Montgomery | ||||
| Marietta | A | 7-25 | L | |
| Ferrum | H | 13-29 | L | |
| Washington & Jefferson | H | 0-50 | L | |
| Methodist | A | 21-55 | L | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | H | 6-44 | L | |
| Randolph-Macon * | A | 3-27 | L | |
| Bridgewater * | H | 17-31 | L | |
| Catholic * | A | 24-21 | W | |
| Washington and Lee * | H | 7-45 | L | |
| Guilford * | A | 6-42 | L | |
| 2006 - (6-4 overall, 4-2 ODAC) | ||||
| Head Coach: Don Montgomery | ||||
| Marietta | H | 20-28 | L | |
| North Carolina Wesleyan | H | 24-21 | W | |
| Apprentice School | A | 16-7 | W | |
| Methodist | H | 8-16 | L | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | A | 21-24 | L | |
| Randolph-Macon * | H | 28-7 | W | |
| Bridgewater * | A | 21-17 | W | |
| Catholic * | H | 31-27 | W | |
| Washington and Lee * | A | 6-24 | L | |
| Guilford * | H | 27-23 | W | |
| 2007 - (0-10 overall, 0-6 ODAC) (all-time series will count wins) | ||||
| Head Coach: Don Montgomery | (coaches' record will count wins) | |||
| Ferrum | A | 50-7 | W* (vacated) | |
| North Carolina Wesleyan | A | 16-20 | L | |
| Apprentice School | H | 35-14 | W* (vacated) | |
| Methodist | A | 13-3 | W* (vacated) | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | H | 29-19 | W* (vacated) | |
| Randolph-Macon * | A | 25-28 | L | |
| Bridgewater * | H | 14-17 | L | |
| Catholic * | A | 21-31 | L | |
| Washington and Lee * | H | 14-17 | L | |
| Guilford * | A | 17-21 | L | |
| 2008 - (6-4 overall, 4-2 ODAC) | ||||
| Head Coach: Don Montgomery | ||||
| Ferrum | A | 26-21 | W | |
| Greensboro | H | 12-14 | L | |
| North Carolina Wesleyan | A | 16-17 | L | |
| Methodist | H | 28-7 | W | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | A | 0-17 | L | |
| Randolph-Macon * | H | 24-10 | W | |
| Bridgewater * | A | 19-14 | W | |
| Catholic * | H | 23-38 | L | |
| Washington and Lee * | A | 17-14 | W | |
| Guilford * | H | 44-7 | W | |
| 2009 - (7-3 overall, 3-3 ODAC) | ||||
| Head Coach: Don Montgomery | ||||
| Ferrum | H | 24-21 | W | |
| Greensboro | W | 31-14 | W | |
| North Carolina Wesleyan | H | 36-34 | W | |
| Methodist | A | 28-3 | W | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | H | 12-23 | L | |
| Randolph-Macon * | A | 0-19 | L | |
| Bridgewater * | H | 34-38 | L | |
| Catholic * | A | 13-10 | W | |
| Washington and Lee * | H | 23-16 | W | |
| Guilford * | A | 17-3 | W | |
| 2010 - (5-5 overall, 1-5 ODAC) | ||||
| Head Coach: Don Montgomery | ||||
| Ferrum | A | 23-17 | W | |
| Greensboro | A | 28-6 | W | |
| UVA-Wise | H | 20-10 | W | |
| Methodist | H | 49-6 | W | |
| Randolph-Macon * | H | 22-34 | L | |
| Washington and Lee * | A | 24-45 | L | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | A | 10-48 | L | |
| Catholic * | H | 31-33 | L | |
| Bridgewater * | A | 10-24 | L | |
| Guilford * | H | 27-3 | W | |
| 2011 - (5-5 overall, 3-4 ODAC) | ||||
| Head Coach: Don Montgomery | ||||
| Ferrum | H | 41-12 | W | |
| Greensboro | H | 38-0 | W | |
| UVA-Wise | A | 30-33 | L | |
| Methodist | A | 34-27 | W | |
| Randolph-Macon * | A | 17-10 | W | |
| Washington and Lee * | H | 14-17 | L | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | H | 36-38 | L | |
| Catholic * | A | 24-28 | L | |
| Bridgewater * | H | 14-27 | L | |
| Guilford * | A | 30-6 | W | |
| 2012 - (0-10 overall, 0-7 ODAC) (all-time series will count wins) | ||||
| Head Coach: Don Montgomery | ||||
| Ferrum | A | 45-36 | W * (vacated) | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) | A | 21-8 | W * (vacated) | |
| Methodist | H | 34-20 | W * (vacated) | |
| Randolph-Macon * | H | 10-22 | L | |
| Washington and Lee * | A | 28-45 | L | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | A | 17-47 | L | |
| Catholic * | H | 15-14 | W * (vacated) | |
| Bridgewater * | A | 21-27 | L | |
| Shenandoah * | H | 20-17 | W * (vacated) | |
| Guilford * | H | 38-10 | W * (vacated) | |
| 2013 - (0-10 overall, 0-7 ODAC) (all-time series will count wins) | ||||
| Head Coach: Don Montgomery | ||||
| Ferrum | H | 49-13 | W * (vacated) | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) | H | 27-21 | W * (vacated) | |
| Methodist | A | 61-22 | W * (vacated) | |
| Randolph-Macon * | A | 20-45 | L | |
| Washington and Lee * | H | 17-21 | L | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | H | 12-33 | L | |
| Catholic * | A | 17-15 | W * (vacated) | |
| Bridgewater * | H | 17-34 | L | |
| Shenandoah * | A | 37-20 | W * (vacated) | |
| Guilford * | A | 31-35 | L | |
| 2014 - (8-2 overall, 5-2 ODAC) | ||||
| Head Coach: Curt Newsome | ||||
| Ferrum | A | 41-12 | W | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) | A | 14-13 | W | |
| Sewanee | A | 44-27 | W | |
| Randolph-Macon * | H | 38-28 | W | |
| Bridgewater * | A | 34-21 | W | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | A | 27-49 | L | |
| Catholic * | H | 62-28 | W | |
| Washington and Lee * | A | 36-9 | W | |
| Shenandoah * | H | 42-34 | W | |
| Guilford * | H | 28-52 | L | |
| 2015 - (6-4 overall, 4-3 ODAC) | ||||
| Head Coach: Curt Newsome | ||||
| Ferrum | H | 55-7 | W | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) | H | 13-30 | L | |
| East Tennessee State | A | 27-24 | W | |
| Randolph-Macon * | A | 31-21 | W | |
| Bridgewater * | H | 31-7 | W | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | H | 28-31 | L | |
| Catholic * | A | 44-24 | W | |
| Washington and Lee * | H | 14-42 | L | |
| Shenandoah * | A | 54-21 | W | |
| Guilford * | A | 30-41 | L | |
| 2016 - (6-4 overall, 5-2 ODAC) | ||||
| Head Coach: Curt Newsome | ||||
| Ferrum | A | 38-39 | L | |
| Brevard | H | 28-14 | W | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) | A | 36-43 | L | |
| Washington and Lee * | A | 23-49 | L | |
| Shenandoah * | H | 33-36 | L | |
| Randolph-Macon * | H | 27-20 | W | |
| Bridgewater * | A | 42-33 | W | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | A | 31-25 | W | |
| Catholic * | H | 38-27 | W | |
| Guilford * | H | 34-7 | W | |
| 2017 - (3-7 overall, 1-5 ODAC) | ||||
| Head Coach: Curt Newsome | ||||
| Ferrum | H | 8-13 | L | |
| Brevard | A | 48-13 | W | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) | H | 46-56 | L | |
| Washington and Lee * | H | 45-42 | W | |
| Shenandoah * | A | 24-47 | L | |
| Randolph-Macon * | A | 29-52 | L | |
| Bridgewater * | H | 23-31 | L | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | H | 30-38 | L | |
| The Apprentice School | A | 37-14 | W | |
| Guilford * | A | 38-42 | L | |
| 2018 - (4-5 overall, 3-4 ODAC) | ||||
| Head Coach: Curt Newsome | ||||
| Ferrum * | A | 45-29 | W | |
| Methodist | H | Cancelled -- Hurricane Florence | ||
| Rochester (N.Y.) | A | 52-17 | W | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | A | 27-56 | L | |
| Thomas More | H | 21-41 | L | |
| Washington and Lee * | A | 29-40 | L | |
| Shenandoah * | H | 52-50 | W | |
| Randolph-Macon * | H | 21-56 | L | |
| Bridgewater * | A | 13-53 | L | |
| Guilford * | H | 70-27 | W | |
| 2019 - (7-3 overall, 6-2 ODAC) | ||||
| Head Coach: Curt Newsome | ||||
| North Carolina Wesleyan | H | 24-31 | L (OT) | |
| Randolph-Macon * | A | 17-20 | L | |
| Bluefield | A | 49-21 | W | |
| Hampden-Sydney * | H | 56-17 | W | |
| Southern Virginia * | A | 56-14 | W | |
| Washignton and Lee * | H | 48-42 | W | |
| Shenandoah * | A | 41-31 | W | |
| Bridgewater * | H | 3-35 | L | |
| Guilford * | A | 38-22 | W | |
| Ferrum * | H | 59-36 | W | |
| 2020* - (3-1 overall, 3-0 ODAC) | ||||
| Head Coach: Curt Newsome | ||||
| Ferrum * | A | 17-0 | W | |
| Southern Virginia * | H | 47-14 | W | |
| Guilford * | H | 47-6 | W | |
| Washington and Lee * | A | Cancelled -- W&L 'opted-out' | ||
| Randolph-Macon | A | 10-13 | L (OT) | |
| ODAC Championship Game | ||||